Skip to Content
Court Filings & Opinions Democracy & Voting Rights

New York v. United States Department of Commerce

Secretary of Commerce Wilbur L. Ross decided to issue a citizenship question for the 2020 Census and the State of New York challenged this decision.

Download Full Report

2019-01-15-574-Findings Of Fact

Pattern

Secretary of Commerce Wilbur L. Ross decided to issue a citizenship question for the 2020 Census and the State of New York challenged this decision.

 

Overview:

Secretary of Commerce Wilbur L. Ross’s decision to add a citizenship question to the 2020 Census was challenged by a coalition of states, cities, and counties. New York and its plaintiffs alleged that the citizenship question would cause a significant undercount because individuals with families that do not have U.S. citizenship status might refrain from filling out the 2020 Census. Having fewer citizens responding to the 2020 Census would then cause a decrease in federal funding. Furthermore, they claim that the Department’s decision was unconstitutional and violated various regulatory and statutory provisions. On January 15, 2019, the U.S. Supreme Court said it was constitutional to include the citizenship question, but that it violated APA.

From the Research Library

More from the Research Library
Voting and Infection Prevention of COVID-19
White Paper Civil Rights

Voting and Infection Prevention of COVID-19

Learn more
2018 Midterm Elections & The Latino Vote
Policy Report Democracy & Voting Rights

2018 Midterm Elections & The Latino Vote

Learn more
Protecting Democracy: Implementing Equal and Safe Access to the Ballot Box During a Global Pandemic
Policy Report Civil Rights

Protecting Democracy: Implementing Equal and Safe Access to the Ballot Box During a Global Pandemic

Learn more
Letter to Fort Bend
White Paper Democracy & Voting Rights

Letter to Fort Bend

Learn more
Latino Policy & Politics Initiative

There is No American Agenda
Without a Latino Agenda